Health and Human Services Secretary Doesn't Understand What Insurance Is

Health and Human Services Secretary Doesn't Understand What Insurance Is - The Daily Beast var _sf_startpt = (new Date()).getTime(); Follow @thedailybeast TUMBLR Home Politics Business Video Entertainment Fashion Books Art Women in the World Newsweek Featured: WITW Summit Travel The Royalist Howard Kurtz David Frum Newsweek Subscriber Help Content Section Health and Human Services Secretary Doesn't Understand What Insurance Is by Megan McArdle Mar 27, 2013 10:13 AM EDT Kathleen Sebelius thinks insurance isn't really insurance unless it covers routine expenses. This is exactly backwards.

How can insurance make everyone better off?  

After all, the insurance company has to make money.  That has to mean that the expected value of the claims they pay out is lower than the expected value of the premiums their customers pay in.  In some sense, then, the expected value of your insurance premium is negative.  

But insurance does make everyone better off, because it covers very large costs that most people would have trouble paying.  Even most really good savers would have a hard time replacing the value of their house, or paying off a $250,000 judgement for an auto accident.  The expected value of those incidencts is very, very negative--more than just the value of the cash, you have to factor in the horror of being homeless or bankrupt.  When you factor in the homelessness, the bankruptcy, and so forth, the slighly negative expected financial value is more than outweighed by the positive value of being protected against personal catastrophe.  Not to mention the peace of mind one gets from not having to worry about homelessness, etc.  

This is the magic of risk pooling.  But notice that it's the catastrophe which makes insurance a good deal.  You wouldn't get much value from buying "grocery insurance".  At best, you'd be paying an extra administrative fee to route your routine expenses through an insurer, rather than paying them directly.  At worst, you'll end up with bills skyrocketing as all sorts of perverse incentives appear.  After all, if the insurer is paying all your grocery claims, why not load up on filet mignon instead of ground turkey?

But insurers try very hard never to sell insurance for less than the cost of your expected claims.  If you expect to buy $10,000 worth of groceries next year, it will not charge you less than that for a "grocery policy".  And if we all drive up the costs of grocery insurance by consuming more, the insurer can do one of two things: raise everyone's "insurance premiums" to cover a filet mignon budget, or create a list of "approved groceries" that it will cover, and start hassling anyone who tries to file an excessively expensive claim.

Sound familiar?

This is why you should always have liability insurance, but should think twice about collision damage coverage.  It's why high deductibles are a good idea--for small expenses, it's better to self insure.  And it's why "catastrophic" health plans, which only cover the sort of extremely expensive events that most people would have difficulty financing, are a much better deal than the soup-to-nuts plans that most people get through their employers.  Those plans are expensive, both because they're paying for a higher percentage of your expenses, and because they drive up utilization--which means that they drive up next year's premiums even more.  Imagine what your car insurance would cost if it covered gasoline, routine maintenance, and those little air freshener trees you hang from the rearview mirror.  Then stop asking why health insurance costs so much.

But Kathleen Sebelius, the Secretary of HHS, thinks that catastrophic insurance isn't really insurance at all.  

At a White House briefing Tuesday, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius said some of what passes for health insurance today is so skimpy it can't be compared to the comprehensive coverage available under the law. "Some of these folks have very high catastrophic plans that don't pay for anything unless you get hit by a bus," she said. "They're really mortgage protection, not health insurance."

She said this in response to a report from the American Society of Actuaries arguing that premiums are going to rise by 32% when Obamacare kicks in, as coverage gets more generous and more sick people join the insurance market.  Sebelius' response is apparently that catastrophic insurance isn't really insurance at all--which is exactly backwards. Catastrophic coverage is "true insurance".  Coverage of routine, predictable services is not insurance at all; it's a spectacularly inefficient prepayment plan.

Now, it occurred to me that Sebelius might be thinking about the scam insurance that is all too often sold to naive, mostly lower-middle-class folks who labor in the service industry.  That stuff isn't insurance at all; it's a fraud, and the people who sell it will richly deserve any justice that is meted out to them in either this life or the next.  But that stuff doesn't protect your mortgage, either; they're almost-worthless discount plans or very-limited-coverage insurance sold by fly-by-night operations who tend to evaporate as soon as claims have to be paid.  So I don't think that's what she's talking about; I think she's talking about catastrophic plans.

Nor do I think that Sebelius is responding awkwardly to a report that the administration would like to wish away.  I think she's sincerely confused about the difference between insurance, and prepayment.  Which explains a lot about the new health law.  

Last week, I was at a health care conference where the subject of catastrophic plans came up.  Obamacare has, unfortunately, sharply curtailed the ability to offer these plans; very high deductible plans are now effectively illegal.  Which is a great shame, because these plans, combined with a dedicated health savings accounts, were showing real promise at controlling costs.  

A liberal policy professor at the event explained this as a result of the toxic political environment surrounding policy these days; since Republicans wouldn't cooperate on Obamacare, Democrats stuck the knife in one of their favorite programs.  

But Sebelius' answer suggests another explanation: the Democratic opposition to castrophic plans was not strategic, or vengeful, but entirely heartfelt.  The Secretary of Health and Human Services genuinely believes that health insurance should do more than just, well, protect your ability to keep paying the mortgage.  Unfortunately, "more" is very expensive and inefficient.

Like The Daily Beast on Facebook and follow us on Twitter for updates all day long.

Megan McArdle is a special correspondent for Newsweek and The Daily Beast covering business, economics, and public policy. A former senior editor at The Atlantic and writer for The Economist, Megan has a diverse work history including three small startups and a disaster recovery firm at Ground Zero.

For inquiries, please contact The Daily Beast at editorial@thedailybeast.com.

You Might Also Like Comments Powered by Livefyre .about-block { float: left; clear: both; width: 99%; border: none; margin: 1em 0 0em; padding: 0;}.about-block header { margin-bottom: 0; color: black; font: normal 30px/1 'TitlingGothicFBMediumComp', 'Arial Narrow', Arial,sans-serif; text-transform: uppercase; text-align: center;}.about-block figure { float: left; position: relative; width: 100%; margin: 0; padding: 0;}.about-block figcaption { margin: -18px 0 40px 155px; text-align: left;}.about-block img.headshot { float:left; margin:6px 1em 6px 0; width:140px; height:140px;}.about-block ul { position: relative; top: 4px; width: 140px; margin: 0;}.about-block a { text-decoration: none; border: none; cursor: pointer;}.about-block li { float: left; border: none; margin: 0; padding: 0; font: 11px Arial, sans-serif;}.about-block li a { display: block;}.about-block li.subscribe-link, .about-block li.subscribe-link span { background-image: url('/content/dam/dailybeast/social-share/bg_social-new.png'); background-repeat: no-repeat;}.about-block li.subscribe-link { background-position: 0 -387px;}.about-block li.subscribe-link a { height: 20px; float: left;}.about-block li.subscribe-link span { color: #666; margin-left: 21px; padding: 4px 6px 4px 2px; height: 28px; line-height: 20px; background-position: right -20px;}.about-block li.twitter-follow-button { width: 140px; height: 20px; margin: 5px 0;}.about-block li.facebook-link { width: 100%; height: 3em; margin: .5em 0 3em;}.about-block h2 { font: normal 30px 'TitlingGothicFBMediumComp', 'Arial Narrow', Arial,sans-serif; text-transform: uppercase; letter-spacing: .04em; margin-top: .75em; display: block;}.about-block h3 { font: italic 16px/1 'TitlingGothicFBMediumComp','Arial Narrow', Arial,sans-serif; text-transform: uppercase; text-align: center; color: #EE3224; display: block;}.about-block p { font: normal 13px/16px Arial,sans-serif; text-align: left; padding-top: 3px; color: #333;} About the Author Subscribe Megan McArdle Megan McArdle is a special correspondent for Newsweek and The Daily Beast covering business, economics, and public policy. A former senior editor at The Atlantic and writer for The Economist, Megan has a diverse work history including three small startups and a disaster recovery firm at Ground Zero.

More from The Daily Beast Full Politics Coverage What Doomed Salam Fayyad? What doomed Salam Fayyad? Peter Beinart on the downfall of an admirable politician.

by Peter Beinart POLITICS Viva Castro! by Andrew Romano National Notebook Downward Spiral by Peter Beinart Politics God and Country by Paul Begala James O’Keefe in Defense of Taping by James O'Keefe Debating Obama's Immigration Announcement Did Obama lock down the independent vote with his move to reform immigration law? Newsweek and The Daily Beast’s Michael Tomasky and David Frum debate the liberal and conservative perspective on the latest immigration reform.

Play Rubio's Lesson on How to Dodge a Question Play Ron Paul: I'm Not Endorsing Romney! Play Obama's Enemies List: Fact or Fiction? Stories We Like Wonderwall Worst Celebrity Fashion Offenders Pop Sugar Justine Timberlake Hits the Wedding Circuit Vulture The 20 Essential Documentaries of the Century International Business Times Why Washington Can't Fix the Economy Your Tango 3 Ways to Spend Your Tax Refund as a Couple Upworthy The One Word You Can’t Put On Your Package If You Want It Delivered On Time Mental Floss 8 Things You May Not Know About Nutella The Cut North Korean Lady Soldiers Wear 4-Inch Heels Rolling Stone Peter Travers on '42' Other News Entertainment Hollywood's Girls Next Door Fashion Hits or Misses: 2013 MTV Movie Awards Is long distance the wrong distance for Kim and Kanye? Get More from Wonderwall Entertainment Patton Oswalt responds to Boston Marathon explosions on Facebook Pulitzer Prize for drama awarded to ‘Disgraced,’ starring ‘Daily Show’ correspondent Aasif Mandvi Celebrities tweet support after Boston marathon explosions Get More from EW.com Entertainment Obama: "American People Will Say A Prayer For Boston Tonight" First Photos From The Scene Of The Boston Marathon Explosion (Extremely Graphic) Candidates In Mass. Senate Race Pulling Ads, Suspending Campaign Activities Get More from Buzz Feed Politics Rodman Says FBI Wants Him to be an Informant Extra Bonus Quote of the Day Did Hugo Chavez's Handpicked Successor Steal the Election? Get More from Political Wire The Daily Beast Help About Contact Us Jobs Advertise Privacy Community Policy Terms of Use Financial Disclaimer Copyright & Trademark Sections: Home Election Entertainment Books Video Women in the World Press Newsweek Subscribe – 1Mth Free Featured: WITW Summit Travel The Royalist Howard Kurtz David Frum Newsweek Subscriber Help Partners: Expedia Hotels Hotwire Merchantcircle Reference Thesaurus Urbanspoon Weather data provided by Weather Underground, Inc. Switch to Mobile © 2013 The Newsweek/Daily Beast Company LLC Get Email Updates Sign Up Sign up for daily email updates from The Daily Beast Rubric if (typeof stLight != 'undefined') { stLight.options({publisher:'3d9f370c-ec3a-4248-b23b-c041cc77078e', onhover:false}); }else{ $.error("Share this could not be loaded: stLight was null"); }

View the original article here