In an increasingly high-tech economy, we cannot continue to handicap students and neglect the workforce needs of our nation. And that is why it is high time the nation addresses the severe shortage of physical science teachers. Far too often, the teacher in a physics or chemistry classroom has neither the content knowledge nor the focused pedagogical education necessary to effectively teach the subject. Only 47 percent of physics and 46 percent of chemistry classrooms are taught by teachers with a degree in the subject. Physics and chemistry top the list of hardest teaching positions to fill year after year.
As a result, students go to college underprepared for demanding courses and unmotivated to pursue STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) courses of study. The situation is unfortunate because STEM disciplines hold great employment opportunities: Overall there are 3.6 unemployed people for every job posting, but in STEM fields, for every unemployed person there are 1.9 job postings. Shortages of STEM workers are particularly acute in the physical sciences where 1 in 4 workers are foreign born.
It is shocking that, despite repeated calls for action stretching over more than 100 years, the situation has improved very little, if at all. Things may soon change. President Obama’s Fiscal Year 2014 budget, released April 10, contains the beginning of a national strategy to address teacher shortages in STEM.
The nation needs a coordinated strategy to ensure that all teachers in the physical sciences are well prepared, not just a small fraction. The Task Force on Teacher Education in Physics (T-TEP), which recently completed a four-year study, found that “the national landscape of professional preparation of physics teachers shows a system that is largely inefficient, mostly incoherent, and completely unprepared to deal with the current and future needs of the nation’s students.”
The good news is we know what works. T-TEP identified several exemplary programs that could serve as models for a more systematic national effort. For instance, Rutgers University runs one of the most active physics and physical science teacher preparation programs in the nation; the program supplies a large number of highly effective teachers to northern New Jersey. School districts express a high degree of satisfaction with these graduates, who receive rigorous preparation, including five courses on physics pedagogy closely integrated with teaching experiences. A national strategy is needed to expand these and similar successes, so they become the norm rather than the exception.
Mr. Obama’s budget contains $265 million in new initiatives for K-12 STEM education, including STEM Innovation Networks that partner school districts with universities and other entities to improve STEM instruction. It is encouraging that this plan is aligned with the central recommendation of the T-TEP report, which is to establish a network of university-based regional centers for educating teachers in physics. However, some critical improvements are needed if STEM Innovation Networks are to become the basis for a successful national program to address the nation’s need for effective teachers in the physical sciences.
One thing we must take into consideration is that not all STEM fields have the same needs. Programs with the label “STEM” tend to neglect physics, partly due to the relatively small numbers of teachers compared to biology. Yet the need is arguably greater. In contrast to the severe shortage of teachers in physics and chemistry, teacher shortages in biology are much less common and a high percentage of biology teachers (73 percent) have a degree in the subject. Teacher shortages in the physical sciences will not be resolved without a concentrated effort specifically in these disciplines. The UTeach program, which has a goal of graduating more STEM teachers, has had great success in math and biology but little impact on physics. By comparison, the Physics Teacher Education Coalition (PhysTEC), which concentrates specifically on physics teachers, has shown dramatic increases in program graduates.
In addition, it is critical to prioritize the education of new teachers. Most of the federal funds are directed toward professional development for practicing teachers, and while professional development is important, this approach is unlikely to solve the shortage of effective teachers in the long run. Practicing teachers who are underprepared to teach physics typically do not have the extensive time required to develop content knowledge and pedagogical skill at a deep enough level. A more robust solution must give top priority to building high quality programs for educating new teachers, so they supply effective teachers in sufficient numbers to meet the national need.
We must make sure our students are ready to compete in a high-tech economy, and that means making sure that every physics and chemistry classroom has a well prepared teacher. With a president who strongly supports STEM education, we have an important opportunity to transform teacher education through establishing regional centers and solving these longstanding teacher shortages. But without getting the details right, we risk continuing the long-established trend of mediocrity.
Vokos is professor of Physics at Seattle Pacific University and is chairman of the Task Force on Teacher Education in Physics (T-TEP).
http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/education/296193-highly-trained-physical-science-teachers-needed-to-educated-students-for-high-tech-economyThe contents of this site are © 2013 Capitol Hill Publishing Corp., a subsidiary of News Communications, Inc. The Hill Archives: Senate | House | Administration | Campaign | Business & Lobbying | Capital Living | OpinionView News by Subject:
Defense & Homeland Security | Energy & Environment | Healthcare | Finance & Economy | Technology | Foreign Policy | Labor | Transportation & InfrastructureGO TO THE HILL HOME » More Videos » Congress Blog
Most Popular StoriesMost ViewedLifting Green Card limit may prove to be best investment of allThe truth about workplace wellness programs: Everybody winsHighly trained physical science teachers needed to educate students for high-tech economyFederal spending: Let the sunshine inEngines for reform: Changing how hospitals deliver careEmailedEngines for reform: Changing how hospitals deliver careThe truth about workplace wellness programs: Everybody winsCollaborative approach needed on Alzheimer's and biopharmaceutical innovationPresident's budget won't narrow the growth gapMore transparency needed from Consumer Product Safety Commission DiscussedOur climate is changing and we must confront that realityProtect rights of artists in new copyright lawArmenia-Azerbaijan region needs a high-level US envoyWorking Families Flexibility Act undermines 40-hour workweekLifting Green Card limit may prove to be best investment of allBlog Home »Most Viewed RSS Feed » More Education HeadlinesLifting Green Card limit may prove to be best investment of allImmigration reform a pivotal point in our educational and economic competitivenessSTEM careers offer bright futuresMore Education Headlines » Education News RSS feed » Congress Blog Topics Campaign » Cardoza's Corner » Civil Rights » Economy & Budget » Education » Energy & Environment » Foreign Policy » Healthcare » Homeland Security » Judicial » Labor » Lawmaker News » Politics » Presidential Campaign » Religious Rights » Technology » The Administration »Briefing RoomObama: 'America needs towns like West'DAY'S END ROUNDUPBloomberg: Tsarnaev brothers planned to detonate explosives in Times Square
More Briefing Room »Congress BlogHighly trained physical science teachers needed to educate students for high-tech economyHagel is not reneging on military benefits The truth about workplace wellness programs: Everybody wins
More Congress Blog »Pundits BlogGeorge W. Bush: A disastrous presidentRepublicans should reimburse taxpayers for the cost of one-party House Benghazi 'report'Mike Lee’s speech: Bring back Judge Napolitano’s 'Freedom Watch'
More Pundits Blog »Twitter RoomJill Biden joins social media network TwitterPriebus says Dems using Boston attack to bolster fundraisingAnthony Weiner returns to Twitter with new handle
More Twitter Room »Hillicon ValleyOVERNIGHT TECH: AT&T fires back at DOJ over airwave auctionHouse Dems call for FTC inquiry into 'Obama phone' websiteGoogle: Government requests to remove political content on the rise
More Hillicon Valley »E2-Wire (Energy)OVERNIGHT ENERGY: Obama’s fracking plans under the microscopeHouse GOP moves to shield oil companies from disclosure ruleSenate panel's paper suggests looking at carbon tax
More E2-Wire (Energy) »Ballot BoxPoll: Paul, Clinton lead 2016 hopefuls in New HampshireRon Paul endorses Mark SanfordOFA targets 9 Republicans, 1 Democrat in gun-control web ads
More Ballot Box »On The MoneyHouse Dem pushes for permanent education tax creditOVERNIGHT MONEY: GD what?Waters calls on regulators to weigh in on Dodd-Frank changes
More On The Money »HealthwatchOVERNIGHT HEALTH: Dems denounce ObamaCare 'exemption'Dem bill would loosen family leave rulesReid: No ObamaCare 'exemption' for lawmakers, staff
More Healthwatch »Floor ActionRubio to immigration reform critics: 'Don’t just be against it, offer ideas'Senate advances online sales tax measureReid: Possible vote 1 a.m. Friday
More Floor Action »TransportationSenate passes measure to end airport delaysBus industry: Why wait for delayed flight? Take a busIn shift, Schumer offers support for shielding FAA from sequester cuts
More Transportation »DEFCON HillUS believes Syria used chemical weapons, risks Obama's ‘red line’OVERNIGHT DEFENSE: Chemical weapons spark calls for actionBoehner: Obama risks emboldening Syria's Assad
More DEFCON Hill »Global AffairsObama administration 'very concerned' with first conviction under Russian NGO lawDems blast GOP over 'false' Benghazi charges on Clinton Lawmaker calls on Obama to demand UN dump official over Boston comments
More Global Affairs »In The KnowOlympic gymnast Aly Raisman would love to train the Obama daughtersKate Walsh: Joe Biden would be 'a good cowboy' on the big screenThe day Bush’s dog almost got away
More In The Know »RegWatchFinancial regulators cite lingering threats to economic recoveryMarkets watchdog: AP Twitter hack shows need for new oversightObama taps FTC official as new regulatory czar
More RegWatch » Blogs News FeedCongress Blog RollCapital GamesDaily KosDCCCDNCDrudge ReportDSCCJudicial WatchNRCCNRSCPolitical AnimalRNCThe ChamberPostThe CornerThe Huffington PostThe NoteThe Plank COLUMNISTSA.B. StoddardAttacks slow reformBrent BudowskyConfirm the judgesMore Columnists »
Get latest news from The Hill direct to your inbox, RSS reader and mobile devices.
Home/NewsNews by SubjectBlogsBusiness & LobbyingOpinionCapital LivingSpecial ReportsJobsVideo Home | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Contact | Advertise | RSS | SubscriptionsThe Hill 1625 K Street, NW Suite 900 Washington DC 20006 | 202-628-8500 tel | 202-628-8503 fax
The contents of this site are © 2013 Capitol Hill Publishing Corp., a subsidiary of News Communications, Inc.
0 comments:
Post a Comment