A middle-aged couple driving through Tennessee on their way home from a funeral were pulled over by a police officer who mistook their Ohio Buckeye bumper stickers for marijuana leaves.
The Columbus Dispatch reports:
Two officers approached, one on each side of the car.
“They were very serious,” [the driver, Bonnie Jonas-Boggioni] said. “They had the body armor and the guns.” […]
“What are you doing with a marijuana sticker on your bumper?” [an officer] asked her.
She explained that it is actually a Buckeye leaf decal, just like the ones that Ohio State players are given to put on their helmets to mark good plays. […]
The officer then explained that someone from outside his jurisdiction — apparently another officer — had spotted the leaf sticker and thought it might indicate that the car was carrying marijuana, Jonas-Boggioni said. […]
The reporter quoted a spokeswoman for the West Tennessee Drug Task Force, who accurately explained that a marijuana sticker is clearly not a sufficient reason to stop a car. To justify a stop, police officers must meet the standard of “reasonable suspicion” that an individual has committed a crime or violation. And a sticker – a classic example of First Amendment expression and nothing more – is nowhere close to reasonable suspicion that the couple were drug traffickers.
This same type of flimsy evidence has justified the hundreds of thousands of “stop-and-frisks” applied arbitrarily and discriminatorily in New York City and elsewhere. A court recently found that police officers in the Bronx lacked that necessary reasonable suspicion for their frequent stops of individuals outside residences for alleged trespassing.
What’s particularly troubling about this incident is that police did not simply spot the stickers in the course of their route and stop the car. They went out of their way to respond to a call reporting “marijuana” stickers and sought that car out. Had the stickers actually portrayed marijuana leaves, and not a football symbol, the officers’ reaction might have been different, although the lack of reasonable suspicion would have been exactly the same. And while the inconvenience of a stop may seem minor, federal district judge Shira A. Scheindlin articulates in her recent stop-and-frisk decision why unconstitutional stops — in and of themselves a harm subject to Fourth Amendment protection – have increasingly “dire and long-lasting” consequences:
The stakes of “field interrogation” by the police have dramatically risen since Terry [v. Ohio, which established the legal standard for stop and frisks,] was decided in 1968. The use of incarceration has increased, sentences have grown, the threat of lengthy incarceration has created new incentives to plead guilty, and the collateral consequences of a conviction — on employment, housing, access to government programs, and even the right to vote or serve on a jury — have become more common and more severe.
The War on Drugs has also since emerged, and with it, a host of other justifications for disproportionately subjecting particular populations to the criminal justice system.
Public support for liberalizing marijuana laws is at an all-time high, and as of the November election, 18 states have legalized the drug, either for medical or recreational purposes. Law enforcement, however, seems unmoved by the legalization movement. According to a \ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\thinkprogress\0116marijuana_crime_arrests.png "0116marijuana_crime_arrests")
The Webster, New York man who fired on firefighters responding to a blaze, killing two, is a felon convicted of manslaughter, according to local police. Webster Police Chief Gerald Pickering told a press conference this morning that the suspect was William Spengler, who served roughly 18 years on manslaughter charges for killing his 92 year old grandmother. Spengler had a number of run-ins with the police after that, according to Pickering.\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\clear.gif){kind=small}
Get Email UpdatesContact Us Go to homepage. The White House Blog Photos & Videos Photo Galleries Video Performances Live Streams Podcasts State of the Union\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\sotuthumb.jpg)
\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\menu_visitor_records.jpg)
\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\main_nav_cant_wait.jpg)
\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\featured_tax_receipt.jpg)
\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\featured_petitions.jpg)
\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\menu_interactive_tour.jpg)
President Obama Calls for a Simpler Refinancing Process 
President Obama to Barnard College: "Fight for a Seat at the Head of the Table" 
President Obama's To-Do List for Congress: Reward American Jobs, Not Outsourcing 
President Obama on Ending the War in Afghanistan President Obama Pays Tribute to Fallen Police Officers 
\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\blog_tout_we_cant_wait.jpg "We Can't Wait")
We Can't Wait\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\jf-feature.jpg "Job Resources for Returning Heroes")
Job Resources for Returning Heroes
End of the Iraq War Subscribe to the White House Blog WHITEHOUSE.GOV IN YOUR INBOXSign up for email updates from President Obama and Senior Administration Officials PHOTOS OF THE DAY 
VIEW PHOTO GALLERIES JUMP TO: Other White House Blogs The White House Blog Middle Class Task Force Council of Economic Advisers Council on Environmental Quality Council on Women and Girls Office of Management and Budget Office of Public Engagement Office of Science & Tech Policy Office of Urban Affairs Open Government Faith and Neighborhood Partnerships US Trade Representative Office National Drug Control Policy Home The White House Blog Photos & Videos Photo Galleries Video Performances Live Streams Podcasts Briefing Room Your Weekly Address Speeches & Remarks Press Briefings Statements & Releases White House Schedule Presidential Actions Legislation Nominations & Appointments Disclosures Issues Civil Rights Defense Disabilities Economy Education Energy & Environment Ethics Fiscal Responsibility Foreign Policy Health Care Homeland Security Immigration Rural Seniors & Social Security Service Taxes Technology Urban Policy Veterans Women The Administration President Barack Obama Vice President Joe Biden First Lady Michelle Obama Dr. Jill Biden The Cabinet White House Staff Executive Office of the President Other Advisory Boards About the White House Inside the White House Presidents First Ladies The Oval Office The Vice President's Residence & Office Eisenhower Executive Office Building Camp David Air Force One White House Fellows White House Internships Tours & Events Our Government The Executive Branch The Legislative Branch The Judicial Branch The Constitution Federal Agencies & Commissions Elections & Voting State & Local Government Resources \ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Obama Care\3\sftr-whgov.gif){kind=small}
En español Accessibility Copyright Information Privacy Policy Contact USA.gov Subscribe to RSS Feeds Apply for a Job